Did Game of Thrones’ lacklustre finale really destroy its legacy?


A yr in the past right this moment, I used to be knackered. I’d spent the earlier six weeks staying up until round four or 5am each Monday to reside weblog Game of Thrones when it streamed on Sky Atlantic in step with the US, sharing my each thought, feeling and horrible joke as the most important present on TV drew to a conclusion.

The truth that I did this as a job, and that this was thought of a productive use of my time, might give an concept about what a popular culture phenomenon Game of Thrones was. It was the most important present on TV, made prompt world stars out of its solid and dominated the dialog for years. Till it didn’t.

On Could 19th 2019, the collection’ remaining episode The Iron Throne aired on HBO, wrapping up a season that was already being known as the fantasy drama’s worst, with an internet petition operating to have it redone from scratch earlier than the tip had even been revealed.

Whereas loads of the hate in direction of the plot developments truly stemmed from issues that occurred in episodes 4 and 5, all of it appeared to coalesce in how folks noticed the finale, which killed off extra primary characters, truncated some storylines and ended others in a manner that folks noticed as unsatisfactory.

Daenerys killed off! Jon rejoining the Night time’s Watch (which shouldn’t nonetheless exist) to do nothing! And want I point out… King Bran the Damaged?

Since then, a reasonably broad consensus has emerged that your entire present was tainted by the way it ended, with folks commonly noting on-line how rapidly your entire collection has exited the favored consciousness. As soon as, Game of Thrones was every part – now, it barely components into dialogue, seven nice years of TV undone by one unhealthy yr.

So what occurred? Did A Tune of Ice and Fireplace really finish on a bum notice? And did Game of Thrones undo years of goodwill with a pair of unhealthy episodes? With the profit of hindsight I’d argue sure – but in addition that one thing comparable would have occurred in the event that they’d been good episodes, too.

For me, Game of Thrones’ nice enchantment was in its ever-increasing scale and ambition – and that doesn’t simply imply large battles or dragon assaults. Each season, we met new characters, launched into new storylines in new places, the story increasing outwards into extra disparate tales that hinted on the huge world during which the present was set. Individuals joked about Game of Thrones’ unwieldy solid checklist and Westeros-hopping storytelling, however that was the purpose – the most important present on TV felt just like the largest present on TV.

After which after 5 seasons of enlargement, the collection creators abruptly modified gear. This factor needed to be ended – every part wanted to be tied up – and so every part grew to become about slicing off inexperienced shoots, pruning the story and funnelling it in direction of George RR Martin’s deliberate conclusion.

What had as soon as been a world of countless prospects started to really feel like an on-rails journey to a vacation spot. We’d spent years wandering in Westeros – and now somebody had grabbed our hand and dragged us to a particular half, saying “OK, time’s up”.

It was galling. And whereas the collection’ conclusion might need felt much less abrupt if present creators David Benioff and DB Weiss had taken longer to get there, I nonetheless discover it exhausting to think about a conclusion that didn’t ultimately encourage these emotions. Storylines would must be chopped off, focussed. Characters would must be left behind. Even when Daenerys had taken an additional yr to barbecue King’s Touchdown, would we have now been happy?

I do generally surprise. In a current interview collection star Carice van Houten regarded again on the collection, describing some of the negativity as “a bit ungrateful”.

“The truth that some folks have been so disillusioned is as a result of every part earlier than that was so good,” she mentioned.

“You’ve had such nice occasions after which yeah, you’re going to be disillusioned as a result of it’s not going to go precisely the way you anticipated. After all, you’re going to have all types of criticisms and I simply thought it was an indication of how good the present was.”

There’s a nugget of reality right here, although for as soon as I’m undecided we are able to put it right down to fan entitlement. One of the issues that made Game of Thrones so distinctive, epic, thrilling and “good” was its large scale, and possibly that was a double-edged, Valyrian metal sword.

Perhaps the worth of that pleasure and success was a commensurate fall when Benioff and Weiss needed to truly repay the chances they’d arrange through the years – regardless of how properly or badly they have been executed.

With that in thoughts, maybe Game of Thrones’ future isn’t growing obscurity in any case. Trying forward followers nonetheless have two extra books from George RR Martin to complete the story his manner, having already gone deeper and additional into his imagined world than the collection ever did.

Additional forward, there’s a minimum of one spin-off TV collection delving much more into Thrones marginalia in Home of the Dragon, reportedly based mostly on Martin’s fictional historical past ebook Fireplace & Blood.

In different phrases, the world of Game of Thrones is opening up once more and delving into the trivialities – which is precisely what made the TV collection such a success within the first place, past the headline-grabbing violence and particular results. If achieved proper, I might think about followers’ love for Westeros rekindling – assuming, of course, that it‘s truly gone out within the first place.

For some, the get together by no means stopped. On a vacation to Dubrovnik (the Croatian metropolis that doubles for King’s Touchdown) final summer season, I used to be struck by simply how a lot Game of Thrones nonetheless dominated.

Clearly, it’s a giant draw for tourism there so tour corporations and outlets are sure to lean on the connection, however each fourth individual you noticed within the metropolis appeared to be sporting a King within the North or Mom of Dragons T-shirt.

Clearly, the North remembers… when the collection was nonetheless good. Or maybe the best way Game of Thrones has slipped away from the popular culture dialog isn’t truly emblematic of folks forgetting it or wiping it from the board solely.

The collection completed – there aren’t any extra episodes – so maybe it’d be weirder if folks did nonetheless speak about it on a regular basis. Perhaps, just like the collection itself, the Game of Thrones dialog is simply dormant.

A yr in the past, Game of Thrones had an unsatisfying ending. For lots of followers, the injuries are nonetheless recent. However by some means, a way, I doubt that was the final we’ll see – or love – of Westeros.

All episodes of Game of Thrones are streaming on NOW TV


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here