‘Framing Britney Spears’ Showcases Conservatorship, Misogynistic Media


From “The Jinx” to “Making A Assassin,” tv docuseries lately have put high-profile circumstances instantly again into the highlight.

As authorized proceedings proceed in Britney Spears’ extremely controversial conservatorship, a brand new FX documentary, “Framing Britney Spears,” will undoubtedly increase questions.

The Princess of Pop has been beneath a conservatorship since 2008, led by her father, Jamie Spears, which means he controls her funds and basically each different side of her life. This previous November, the celebrity misplaced a bid to take away her father from her conservatorship. He now stays in management, as co-conservator with monetary firm Bessemer Belief, although the decide didn’t rule out future petitions for his elimination or suspension.

Nonetheless, Spears took a powerful stance, refusing to carry out so long as her father stays in management.

“My consumer has knowledgeable me that she is afraid of her father,” Britney Spears’ lawyer Samuel D. Ingham III informed the decide in late 2020. “She is not going to carry out once more if her father is answerable for her profession.”

All of this comes amid the continued #FreeBritney marketing campaign, a motion led by Spears’ diehard followers — the Britney Military — who imagine the singer is being managed by her father towards her will. #FreeBritney has gone viral on social media, and her followers have joined in protest outdoors of courthouse proceedings.

That is the crux of the brand new documentary “Framing Britney Spears,” which debuted this weekend on FX and is now streaming on Hulu. Produced alongside The New York Occasions, the doc is predicated on the newsroom’s reporting all through the conservatorship case.

Ever since Spears broke out into worldwide fame as a teen, she has been preventing towards nauseating press consideration with a sexist narrative framing her astronomical rise to superstardom — and fall, because the media has so lengthy portrayed it.

Whereas digging into the conservatorship at its core, the documentary is ready towards a backdrop of the misogynistic world of the late ’90s and early 2000s that’s stunningly offensive, watching by way of the lens of 2021. Going through overwhelming tabloid publicity and societal pressures that by no means needed to let her win, the doc showcases a aspect of Spears that has not often been celebrated within the media over the course of her two-decade profession: fiercely unbiased, strong-willed and extremely resilient.

In fact, that is one thing that Spears’ followers have all the time identified — which is why they’ve so passionately stood behind her all through the #FreeBritney motion, and gained’t again down till they imagine justice has been served. And “Framing Britney Spears” raises questions that can completely add gas to the fireplace.

“The primary factor that’s getting expressed by the #FreeBritney motion is asking us to query the conservatorship system,” producer and director Samantha Stark of The New York Occasions tells Selection.

“The central thriller of our movie is that she’s dwelling the lifetime of a busy pop star, and but we’re being informed that she’s in danger continuously. She’s making hundreds of thousands of {dollars}, and but, we’re informed she’s incapable of creating choices which are in her personal finest curiosity,” Stark says. “That’s such a battle, so it’s exhausting to grasp why it’s taking place, and so lots of the court docket data are sealed.”

Right here, Selection speaks with the filmmaker in regards to the misogynistic media surrounding Spears and what she found by way of her reporting in regards to the conservatorship…

You reached out to Britney’s relations, however none of them participated on this piece. Why not?

A professional motive that she and her household wouldn’t converse to any media outlet proper now’s that they’re in the midst of what seems to be gearing as much as be a court docket battle, and it’s customary for attorneys to advise their purchasers to not converse to the media once they’re in the midst of that. We reached out to everybody in each manner we may think about — by way of publicists, attorneys, household mates, individuals who lived on their avenue. We needed to make an enormous try for everybody.

The documentary states that you’re not sure in case your request for Britney’s participation ever made it to her. What ought to viewers take away from that?

We tried each which strategy to get a smoke sign to Britney in regards to the documentary, however there may be such a good circle round her that we don’t know if she acquired these requests or not. We didn’t a “no” from her. We by no means acquired something from her.

It’s very uncommon that Britney talks to the media as of late. Why is that?

If you happen to’ve accomplished any interview together with her for the previous 5 to 10 years, it was beneath cautious watch from her handlers. We’ve heard from lots of people in newsrooms that if you wish to interview Britney, her crew has remaining lower over what’s within the piece. Loads of information shops wouldn’t comply with that, ethically — so you’ll be able to’t have a journalist ask her how she’s feeling. The one factor you’ll be able to see is her Instagram.

Are you aware how a lot management she has over her Instagram and social media?

It’s unclear how a lot of that she controls. Loads of celebrities have social media managers.

Lots of Britney’s followers imagine she is sending secret messages by way of her social media. Primarily based in your reporting, do you imagine that she is sending a cry for assist from her Instagram?

The factor about that’s you’ll be able to’t ask Britney if she wants assist as a result of there’s such a good cone of silence round her that’s enabled by the conservatorship. One of many issues {that a} conservator of Britney’s individual can do is restrict who visits her, they’ll present 24/7 safety for her, so when you name Britney’s publicist or supervisor, you’re not going to get an interview. It appears like her Instagram is the one place you’ll be able to truly hear from her. I have a look at Britney’s Instagram day-after-day to see if there’s a brand new submit and if I can look into it. We don’t know what’s in her head, and he or she by no means talks in regards to the conservatorship, so I perceive why followers are questioning if she’s sending messages by way of her social media.

The documentary showcases archival footage from interviews the place Britney is requested by a male journalist about her breasts. She’s additionally requested throughout a press convention about her virginity. She didn’t say a lot, however she pushed again. She was very resilient with the press, however that by no means acquired consideration. 

That was new to me, too. I didn’t understand that. Everybody imagined that Britney was this puppet who was being managed by these older male executives after which she “went loopy” and that’s all they give thought to her — however once you have a look at this footage, she is so younger and also you see that she was in management. It was vital when revisiting all of the media protection that was so mean-spirited to her that we included all the pieces we may discover the place she was preventing again and expressing a special opinion than what the journalist needed her to specific.

It’s surprising to look at that footage. At the moment, a feminine celeb would discuss again to the journalist asking these inappropriate questions, and the journalist can be canceled on social media for asking the query.

It wasn’t that way back. These had been between 2000 and 2008. To assume that now, it will by no means occur, it’s actually shocking. This wasn’t deep historical past when this was taking place.

You might be proper in that there was all the time a story that she was a puppet. Out of your reporting, what did you find out about how in management she was over her profession within the early days?

From everybody I spoke to, it was described to me that she helped contribute creatively to her picture. It wasn’t placed on her. This didn’t make it into the ultimate lower, however throughout an interview, I used to be informed that one time Britney and her stylist had been within the inexperienced room for a morning present and Britney rotated and took scissors and made her shirt right into a crop prime. The stylist stated, “That’s Britney! We are able to’t management her.”

How did the overwhelming media consideration have an effect on Britney in her early years?

I talked to Hayley Hill, who was a trend director at “Teen Folks,” after which she turned a stylist for Britney and have become superb mates with Britney. She stated that she remembers Britney crying and that it affected her so much. While you’re a youngster and there’s a grown man shaming you on your sexuality, which you’re nonetheless making an attempt to determine, what are you speculated to say? Some extent that Hayley made is that after she was shamed a lot for her sexuality from the “Child One Extra Time” period, she stopped making an attempt to please all people. And that’s a lesson all ladies be taught; she simply discovered it actually early. I believe that’s unknown about Britney, however once you watch the footage, it’s true — she didn’t shrink again when all these adults had been telling her that she’s a foul instance for his or her youngsters. She truly took extra management. I believe that’s why she wore stomach shirts on a regular basis — as a result of individuals informed her to not.

What did individuals share with you about how she handled the damaging consideration and slut-shaming on the time?

Hayley and Felicia [Culotta, who was Spears’ former assistant] bear in mind her crying within the bathtub and getting upset, however they only needed to hold going. However they spoke about how she had these followers who cherished her so unconditionally and it was at the moment that her followers turned so vital to her. When she’s on the stage, there isn’t a judgement. She actually took solace on this concept that she may exit and carry out for her followers and know that she may belong there. 

How do you assume that kind of hyper-sexualization impacted her psyche?

I don’t know what’s in Britney’s psyche, and I used to be very cognizant of that once we had been making this. So many individuals wish to psycho-analyze her with out realizing her, however I believe Britney’s story is one thing that’s consultant of what occurs to women all over the place — she is that this celebrated artist after which she begins getting shamed for being too attractive after which she will get in hassle for apparently dishonest on Justin after which individuals name her a slut. Folks really feel like they’ll say no matter they need about you. That occurs in excessive faculties all over the place. And, in fact, it damages individuals.

Talking of Justin Timberlake, did you attain out to him for this documentary?

We didn’t ask Justin Timberlake for remark, similar to we didn’t ask various different individuals who seem in archival footage for remark. Interviewees make factors in regards to the media protection surrounding the breakup, and NYT’s critic-at-large assesses a music video from a really profitable album. Not like different individuals who we did ask for remark, we don’t make any allegations towards Justin. We merely let the footage play…A lot protection about Britney revolves across the males in her life, and we actually needed to not make it in regards to the boyfriends and her relationships. They did have an effect on what occurred to her, however we didn’t wish to concentrate on them. Britney has a lot say for herself.

Tabloid tradition was at an all time excessive within the early 2000’s. The paparazzi had an immense quantity of energy as a result of celeb pictures offered for a whole lot of 1000’s of {dollars}. These days, celebrities submit their very own pictures on social media. How completely different was Britney’s path to stardom than the younger stars breaking by way of immediately?

The trade isn’t the identical in any respect. It was actually exhausting to select what to placed on display as a result of a number of it could possibly be re-traumatizing for Britney. It was form of a dance to determine tips on how to use simply sufficient to confront us with our personal complicity and look again at issues which are so shocking now.

Except for the tabloid and paparazzi tradition throughout Britney’s rise, nobody was speaking about psychological well being at the moment. These days, we see stars like Selena Gomez and Demi Lovato brazenly discussing psychological well being.

We didn’t speak about that again then. Why did individuals wish to see a prepare wreck? I believe it’s modified as a result of a brand new era is in cost now. The general public consuming this media again then had been of their 30’s, 40’s, 50’s, and Britney was a youngster. The general public in media condemning her had been that age. Now, most people in media and who’re operating magazines are nearer to Britney age’s.

The media protection surrounding Britney Spears, even to this present day, is so damaging. She is commonly framed as a “loopy” individual.

We don’t know if Britney has a psychological sickness. That’s a rumor within the media. Her medical data are sealed. No person is aware of. One of many causes it’s known as “Framing Britney Spears” is as a result of we needed to drag out of the reframes about her — whether or not it’s shaving her head or no matter — and present you what else what taking place, and attempt to right the narrative, realizing what was outdoors the pictures that we noticed.

Within the documentary, an govt from Jive Information alludes to the truth that Jamie Spears spoke about cash from the day he walked into their places of work when Britney was a teen. Primarily based in your reporting, is it your finest judgment that Britney’s father is profiting from her and is solely thinking about her cash?

I don’t know, however many individuals we interviewed stated issues that point out that. Lots of people didn’t wish to go on digital camera and say that. What we do know is that he struggled with alcohol and went to rehab when Britney was younger. It seems he was not an enormous a part of her life initially. It was so exhausting of us to search out any picture of him together with her. You see her together with her mother and her siblings so much, but it surely’s exhausting to search out pictures of him — so you’ll be able to take what you need from that. He has stated himself that he wasn’t round so much. He and Britney’s mother, Lynne, acquired divorced as Britney was rising, and we all know that the 2 of them filed for chapter very near when Britney hit it huge when she was ending up her first report. To consider that, you’re 15 or 16 years outdated, your dad and mom are struggling and you don’t come from a wealthy background, and you’ve got the chance to assist your entire household? That’s so much. 

Britney was so younger and so many individuals had been profiting off of her — which is likely one of the issues with childhood fame. Throughout the early days of her success, did Britney understand her incomes energy?

Hayley informed this story that’s not within the doc. They had been giving Britney completely different Barbie dolls that had been going to be Britney dolls and so they had been selecting out the garments for the Barbies to put on. She stated to Britney, “You’re going to make 1,000,000 {dollars} from these,” and Britney stated “Hopefully extra!” Hayley stated she was so floored that this teenager had this enterprise sensibility. I convey that up as a result of Britney was in a position to make cash so her household wouldn’t battle, and he or she knew that.

Quick ahead to immediately, and though Britney’s father is in command of her funds, she’s paying for him and he’s profiting off of her. That appears a bit backwards, no?

The movie shines a highlight on the conservatorship system as a result of Britney is deemed incapable of hiring her personal lawyer, so she was appointed an lawyer that she has been paying for the previous 13 years. The best way the system is ready up, she pays for her lawyer, for her conservators and for her conservators’ attorneys. Britney proper now’s submitting for her father to not be in cost and he or she’s paying for her personal attorneys and her fathers attorneys which are preventing towards her attorneys. It was estimated final 12 months at $1.2 million in authorized charges, and I might think about it will be extra this 12 months as a result of extra is going on. So, it’s actually complicated. 

Why was the dad put answerable for the conservatorship, within the first place? It seems that Britney has a a lot nearer relationship together with her mom. Why wouldn’t she be put in cost?

That’s an excellent query. The form of conservatorship that Britney is beneath is the type that’s typically used for individuals with Alzheimer’s — the purpose of it’s to guard the individual and act because the individual would have acted as in the event that they had been of their proper thoughts, so whoever is the conservative is meant to know what’s within the individual’s finest curiosity and know the way they might act. With Britney, it’s actually odd as a result of she was 26. That is normally for an individual who’s dying, and a member of the family is normally in cost, and it’s so exhausting to get out of a conservatorship as a result of the individual normally dies throughout it. Any person, normally a member of the family, has to file for it and so they nominate themselves or one other individual to do it. So, her father was the one who filed for it. From what we all know, her mom wasn’t on the submitting. That’s how the system works.

It’s clearly extra sophisticated than this as a result of the courts needed to approve the conservatorship, however basically, Britney’s father got here up with the concept that she wanted to be beneath a conservatorship, he nominated himself, he was appointed to be in cost and now he stays in cost. Is {that a} honest understanding of the conservatorship course of?

When you’re in it, it’s very uncommon to get out of it as a result of it’s normally arrange for individuals who had been going to die, whereas they’re beneath a conservatorship. So, Britney is on this authorized tangle, it appears. It looks as if a Catch 22 as a result of with a purpose to get out, it’s your burden of proof, so if Britney needs to get out of the conservatorship, she has to show that she is able to managing her personal life and dealing with her personal cash — however how do you show that when you’re a beneath a conservatorship the place you’ll be able to’t deal with your individual life and your individual cash?

Britney went proper again to work in 2008 on the “Circus” tour, and was a visitor star on “How I Met Your Mom.” There was a number of hypothesis that it was too quickly, and that she turned very worthwhile once more — which advantages her father. Did she wish to return to work?

It’s fairly shocking that two months after the conservatorship is in place, she is visitor starring in a TV present. She introduced a number of consideration to that present when she did that. Loads of this stuff that she did, not solely had been they getting cash for her crew, however there may be a lot cash being made on Britney that she is getting cash for everybody. There’s a contradiction that she made fortunes for therefore many individuals, however she will be able to’t make her personal fortunes immediately.

The plain query that individuals have been asking for years is: if she’s so match to work, why does she must be beneath a conservatorship?

I believe it’s legitimate to ask that query. Conservatorship is meant to be a final resort.

There was a number of hypothesis about why Britney abruptly canceled her second Vegas residency in 2019. Is it honest to attach the dots between her not transferring ahead together with her Vegas residency and her father being in management?

We don’t know as a result of Britney has by no means informed us. However she canceled this residency, and we heard it was an enormous shock to individuals engaged on the residency. Evidently it was a choice that was made when all the pieces was nearly prepared — we heard they had been ending making her costumes. One other factor that occurred round that point is that Kevin Federline acquired a restraining order towards Jamie for the youngsters due to a bodily altercation between him and one of many sons — so Britney’s father has a restraining order and may’t see her youngsters. All of this stuff had been taking place round the same time. I don’t know, however there seems to be a connection.

What’s her relationship with Kevin Federline immediately?

From what we’ve heard, she and Kevin Federline are superb co-parents and everybody principally stated that they’ve a very good relationship. We heard that from multiple individual.

What’s their custody settlement?

I don’t know. We haven’t been capable of finding something.

When Britney’s lawyer stated in a court docket submitting that she wouldn’t carry out till her dad was not in cost, that was an enormous turning level for the #FreeBritney motion. What was the importance of that letter?

These filings had been mind-blowing once they got here out as a result of there have been so little modifications for therefore a few years that it was so shocking to everybody. We had been filming for some time when these got here out, and we modified the entire narrative after that. She is for positive indicating that she doesn’t need her father answerable for her enterprise dealings and her cash. Her lawyer is saying that she is refusing to carry out till her father isn’t answerable for the conservatorship. That may be a huge stance.

Britney additionally acknowledged the followers within the authorized letter. How a lot has the followers involvement by way of the #FreeBritney motion made an affect?

That was the primary time she has acknowledged the #FreeBritney motion, and it was actually shocking, but in addition a really assertive factor to say. The submitting stated that Britney doesn’t wish to hold this locked away like a household secret and that the entire world is watching, so she is indicating that she needs one thing to vary and perhaps acknowledging that the #FreeBritney followers are onto one thing.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here