Joss Whedon’s Cutting and Toxic Set of ‘Buffy’ and ‘Angel’


Buffy the Vampire Slayer” was set at a California highschool beset by vampires, demons and poisonous imply women, but it surely seems its real-life huge unhealthy was the present’s creator, Joss Whedon.

Then in his early 30s, Whedon — who constructed “Buffy” into one of probably the most beloved and influential exhibits of the previous 25 years and went on to jot down and direct 2012’s “The Avengers,” which launched the largest film franchise of all time — was heralded for his witty dialogue and wrenching plot twists. However he additionally scarred his solid of younger actors with biting, inappropriate feedback that stayed with them for many years.

Interviews that Selection performed with 11 people who labored immediately on “Buffy” or “Angel,” or had been carefully aware of the productions throughout their runs on The WB and UPN, painted a portrait of Whedon as a proficient, collaborative writer-producer with a sample of inappropriate, imperious and disparaging habits towards those that labored for him. Whedon created a “cult of character” round himself, based on these sources. These on the within of Whedon’s circle basked in his consideration, reward and friendship; these on the surface bought the other: scorn, derision and callousness. (Everybody Selection spoke with did so on situation of anonymity, both so they might communicate freely or out of concern for his or her careers.)

Selection additionally reached out to 40 different actors, writers, producers and administrators from “Buffy” and “Angel” — together with Sarah Michelle Gellar, Michelle Trachtenberg, Amber Benson, Eliza Dushku, David Boreanaz and Alyson Hannigan — all of whom declined to take part on this story.

Whedon’s tenure on “Buffy” and “Angel” got here beneath scrutiny on Feb. 10 after Charisma Carpenter, who performed reformed imply woman Cordelia Chase for 3 seasons on “Buffy” and 4 seasons on its spinoff, “Angel,” posted a prolonged assertion to social media by which she alleged that Whedon “abused his energy on quite a few events” together with her whereas engaged on the exhibits. Carpenter known as Whedon “casually merciless” and alleged that after Whedon discovered she was pregnant whereas making “Angel,” he requested her in a closed-door assembly “if I used to be ‘going to maintain it,’ and manipulatively weaponized my womanhood and religion in opposition to me. He proceeded to assault my character, mock my non secular beliefs, accuse me of sabotaging the present, and then unceremoniously fired me following the season as soon as I gave beginning.”

A supply who labored with Carpenter when she was on “Buffy” and “Angel” corroborated her story with Selection, saying that Carpenter would typically focus on the mistreatment on the time, characterizing it as “very, very unhealthy,” “mean-spirited” and “verbal abuse.”

Whedon declined to touch upon Carpenter’s allegations when she first made them, and declined to remark when contacted by Selection for this story.

Lazy loaded image

Charisma Carpenter and Sarah Michelle Gellar in “Buffy the Vampire Slayer”
twentieth Century Fox/Courtesy Everett Assortment

Carpenter’s put up launched a domino impact of related allegations in opposition to Whedon, establishing an obvious sample of habits on the exhibits. Neither Whedon nor his representatives have responded to any of the social media claims.

Quite a few actors and writers from Whedon’s sequence “Buffy,” “Angel” and “Dollhouse” expressed their assist for Carpenter on social media, together with stars Gellar, Boreanaz and Dushku, and government producer Marti Noxon. Benson, who performed the shy Wiccan Tara on “Buffy” for 3 seasons, was one of the primary to reply. She posted that the present was a “poisonous surroundings and it begins from the highest,” and that “there was rather a lot of injury completed throughout that point and many of us are nonetheless processing it twenty plus years later.” Nicholas Brendon, finest recognized for taking part in the wisecracking Xander Harris on “Buffy” from 1997 to 2003, was awaiting spinal surgical procedure when he weighed in from his hospital mattress, sharing on Fb that he had skilled “transgressions” with Whedon. “There’s rather a lot of kindness, but additionally rather a lot of not,” Brendon stated.

Probably the most troubling assertion got here from Trachtenberg, who performed Buffy’s youthful sister, Daybreak, on three seasons of the present, beginning when she was 15. In an Instagram put up, Trachtenberg characterised Whedon’s habits as “not applicable.” In a later replace to the caption, she alleged there was a “rule” on the set that Whedon was forbidden to be alone in a room together with her.

Whereas a number of high-placed sources who labored on “Buffy” say they weren’t conscious of this rule, an individual with direct data of the manufacturing on the time confirms to Selection that an effort was made by these round Trachtenberg to make sure the younger actor was by no means alone with Whedon. In line with this particular person, it was as a consequence of an improper verbal change between Whedon and Trachtenberg.

A consultant for Trachtenberg declined to remark.

Nobody doubts Whedon’s manifest abilities as a storyteller, nor his dedication to centering complexly rendered girls on his exhibits when few others had been. However because the trade continues to reckon with entrenched energy buildings which have enabled — and normalized — rampant misconduct, it is smart that the story of how Whedon handled these round him is resurfacing now.

Lazy loaded image

Joss Whedon speaks onstage at San Diego Comedian-Con in 2018.
Albert L. Ortega/Getty Pictures

“Buffy” and “Angel” aired within the late Nineteen Nineties and early 2000s, lengthy earlier than the #MeToo motion, when the trade extra freely abetted on-set misconduct to be able to preserve high expertise completely satisfied and working. Hollywood nonetheless has a protracted solution to go in making certain secure and equitable workplaces, however what makes the allegations by the “Buffy” and “Angel” actors particularly troubling is that they arrive on the heels of latest, mounting claims of misbehavior by Whedon. In July 2020, “Justice League” actor Ray Fisher alleged that Whedon acted in a “gross, abusive, unprofessional, and fully unacceptable” method on the set of the 2017 superhero film, feedback that had been publicly supported by Fisher’s A-list co-stars Gal Gadot (“Surprise Girl”) and Jason Momoa (“Aquaman”). Within the center of WarnerMedia’s investigation into Fisher’s claims, Whedon abruptly departed the sci-fi fantasy sequence “The Nevers,” which he created and government produced for HBO. (WarnerMedia, which launched the “Justice League” investigation, is the father or mother firm of HBO.)

A number of high-placed sources say if there have been any complaints about Whedon on the units of “Buffy” or “Angel,” they by no means rose to the studio degree or grew to become an official matter with human sources. Nor did those that spoke with Selection have data of any payouts or settlements relating to Whedon’s alleged habits whereas “Buffy” was in manufacturing.

twentieth Tv, the studio behind “Buffy” and “Angel,” declined to remark.

In line with sources, after Whedon created “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” in 1997, he was largely left alone, working on a decent price range with little oversight, due to a gentle stream of robust media buzz and wealthy key-demo scores. The present shot at a comparatively distant location on soundstages in Santa Monica the place executives weren’t frequently roaming round, and the manufacturing operated very similar to an indie movie. Insiders say the mixture of Whedon’s lack of expertise operating a tv present, the monetary pressures of delivering an action-and-effects-heavy hourlong dramedy, a solid largely populated with younger and keen actors, and the absence of common supervision contributed to an surroundings ripe for a chaotic, extremely aggressive, poisonous office. Many individuals who spoke with Selection described the set as working like highschool, with Whedon making everybody conscious of who was in and who was out.

One other main issue contributing to the messy nature of the “Buffy” set: Tales of Whedon participating in affairs with girls engaged on the present shortly unfold, based on three impartial sources. As the chief producer and showrunner, Whedon was the boss, together with of the ladies with whom he engaged in relationships. The alleged habits contributed to a poisonous office and heightened competitors on set, blurring the traces between private and skilled demeanor for the solid — dynamics that continued lengthy after Whedon’s purported affairs ended.

These sources echo allegations made by Whedon’s ex-wife, Kai Cole, who in August 2017 wrote in The Wrap that Whedon had engaged in a number of affairs along with his actors and co-workers, beginning when he was making “Buffy.” In line with Cole, Whedon admitted the affairs to her in writing and wrote to her, “I used to be surrounded by lovely, needy, aggressive younger girls. It felt like I had a illness, like one thing from a Greek delusion. All of the sudden I’m a strong producer and the world is laid out at my toes and I can’t contact it.” On the time, a spokesperson for Whedon stated Cole’s account “consists of inaccuracies and misrepresentations.”

“Buffy” and “Angel” had grueling schedules, taking pictures 22 episodes a season, typically at evening. Actors requiring elaborate make-up may find yourself clocking 21-hour days, and shoots generally didn’t wrap till 4 a.m. It was frequent for manufacturing on a Friday to bleed into Saturday morning, wiping out any probability for the solid and crew to take pleasure in a full weekend off. The follow even had a reputation: Fraterdays.

Lazy loaded image

Michelle Trachtenberg, Joss Whedon, and Amber Benson at a launch occasion for the “Buffy” musical episode solid recording, in 2002.
Albert L. Ortega/WireImage/Getty

In that high-pressure manufacturing surroundings, the “Buffy” set was typically aggressively grownup, with inappropriate and chopping jokes flying behind the scenes. One supply with detailed data of the manufacturing remembers Trachtenberg’s mom expressing frustration as a result of the set ambiance was inappropriate for a younger teenager.

Whedon was “each feared and idolized” by the actors on the present, says an individual who was half of the group overseeing “Buffy” throughout its run. He might be fulsome along with his consideration with one of his favorites, and “sharp-tongued” when he was displeased.

For Carpenter, it seems, that dynamic began early. In line with a person who held a high place near the present in its early years, Whedon was pushed by the community to solid Carpenter on “Buffy,” however he was by no means a giant fan of her work. He’d regularly choose on her, and the supply says some writers on the present, following Whedon’s lead, had been overtly dismissive of Carpenter’s performing abilities. Two separate individuals in excessive positions associated to the present recall inner complaints referring to Carpenter’s tardiness on set that led to manufacturing delays and contributed to a common sense of unwell feeling for the actor, emotions Whedon weaponized into an surroundings by which Carpenter wasn’t handled with respect.

The one who labored carefully with Carpenter whereas she starred on “Buffy” and “Angel” remembers the actor regularly describing Whedon as being “mean-spirited” and “verbally abusive” towards her, making it apparent to her that he had favorites — and she was not one of them. “That was his sport,” this particular person says of Whedon. Taking part in favorites led to simmering animosity among the many solid, based on a number of sources, each from the studio and the writers’ room.

One producer says the writers on “Buffy” loved writing for Carpenter’s character. However, the supply provides, the angle round Carpenter grew extra hostile after she moved over to “Angel,” the place she was finally written off the present after her being pregnant.

A spokesperson for Carpenter declined to remark for this story.

Even Whedon’s high star apparently had problem with him. Two sources aware of the manufacturing say that pretty early into the present’s run, Gellar had a severed relationship with Whedon, to the extent that she didn’t need his identify spoken round her. That made for awkwardness on set. Though Whedon moved on from being the day-to-day showrunner on “Buffy” in 2001, he was nonetheless the general government producer, and was writing and directing episodes till the sequence led to 2003.

Lazy loaded image

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Joss Whedon on the set of “Buffy the Vampire Slayer,” with the solid within the background.
Robert Gauthier/Los Angeles Occasions by way of Getty Pictures

After Carpenter’s allegations of Whedon’s cruelty, Gellar made an announcement on Instagram that learn, partly, “Whereas I’m proud to have my identify related to Buffy Summers, I don’t wish to be without end related to the identify Joss Whedon.” She continued, “I stand with all survivors of abuse and am proud of them for talking out.”

A consultant for Gellar didn’t reply to Selection‘s request for touch upon this story.

A standard chorus about Whedon is that his concept of a very good joke entailed being biting and downright nasty. “It was not enjoyable to be on the butt finish of his humor,” says one supply.

Nell Scovell, creator of “Sabrina the Teenage Witch,” skilled Whedon’s inappropriate humor early throughout “Buffy’s” run. In 1998, when she was pregnant and two weeks from her due date, she met with Whedon and “Buffy” government producer David Greenwalt for a attainable writing job. As Scovell relates in her 2018 memoir, “Buffy” was her favourite tv present, so she took the assembly. She writes that Joss “took one take a look at me and stated, ‘Boy, are you fats.’ I laughed so exhausting, I believed I used to be going to have the newborn. David Greenwalt adopted up by asking, ‘Ought to I put down a tarp?’” Scovell didn’t get the job. (Greenwalt didn’t reply to a request for remark.)

“‘Casually merciless’ is an ideal method of describing Joss,” Jose Molina, who was a author on Whedon’s short-lived, much-loved sci-fi sequence “Firefly” in 2002 and 2003, posted on Twitter on Feb. 12. “He thought being imply was humorous. Making feminine writers cry throughout a notes session was particularly hysterical. He really favored to boast concerning the time he made one author cry twice in a single assembly.”

Scovell and Molina each declined Selection‘s requests to remark additional.

Whereas these working beneath Whedon weathered his mercurial habits, the powers that be above him seen him as a collaborative worker — a captivating producer who understood budgets and by no means complained about doing press to advertise his exhibits. There’s a common sense amongst those that spoke with Selection that Whedon knew methods to “handle up,” and acted otherwise towards these he labored for versus those that labored for him. All of the sources had been emphatic that they imagine the ladies and males who’ve come ahead.

The allegations in opposition to Whedon are particularly troubling given his public persona as an outspoken feminist. “He created this girl-power character with Buffy Summers that ladies rallied round,” says an individual who labored on “Buffy.” “Lastly, we bought to see a lady kicking ass. It was an important function mannequin for girls and women. That was the area that he was proud to occupy and actually pioneered. The concept he had this darker aspect is creepy and upsetting — and exhausting to sq. with, given his work.”

Lazy loaded image

Whedon in 2014 on the set of “Avengers: Age of Ultron” with Elizabeth Olsen and Jeremy Renner.
Disney/Courtesy Everett Assortment

When “The Avengers” debuted in 2012 with the very best opening weekend of all time, Whedon’s profession hit its highest peak, and he started working with a brand new echelon of actors — Robert Downey Jr., Scarlett Johansson and Mark Ruffalo amongst them — whose clout far exceeded his personal. After Whedon wrote and directed 2015’s “Avengers: Age of Ultron,” which was additionally a monster hit, Warner Bros. basically poached him to make a Batgirl film, then enlisted him to avoid wasting what the studio believed to be the troubled manufacturing of its personal superhero team-up film, “Justice League.”

That was the start of a steep profession downturn from which Whedon has by no means actually recovered. He took the reins of “Justice League” from Zack Snyder, who, after successfully taking pictures most of the movie, left the manufacturing as a consequence of inventive variations with the studio and to deal with a household tragedy. Whedon reportedly rewrote and re-shot roughly 75% of Snyder’s work; the ensuing movie was panned by critics and underperformed (given its price range and advertising prices) on the field workplace, dropping many hundreds of thousands for the studio. In Feb. 2018, he introduced he was now not making “Batgirl.”

Then, in the summertime of 2020, Fisher’s allegations hit.

Whereas Whedon has stayed quiet about what occurred on “Justice League,” its stars haven’t. Gadot not too long ago confirmed to Selection that she had been interviewed for the WarnerMedia investigation. In one other interview with the Los Angeles Occasions, the “Surprise Girl” star stated she endured her personal “expertise” with Whedon, which she stated “wasn’t the most effective”; whereas she didn’t elaborate additional, she stated she introduced the difficulty to high-ranking executives on the studio.

A consultant for Gadot was not obtainable for additional remark.

In her put up in February, Carpenter stated she additionally spoke to the “Justice League” investigators and determined to lastly come ahead about her experiences with Whedon to be able to assist Fisher.

In December, WarnerMedia introduced the investigation had concluded and that “remedial motion has been taken.” A month earlier, Whedon introduced he was leaving “The Nevers,” which is ready to premiere in April with out his involvement. Whedon cited the pressures of manufacturing in the course of the pandemic as the explanation for his departure; HBO executives have stated “no complaints” had been made about Whedon earlier than his exit.

Fisher, nonetheless, claimed on social media that Whedon’s departure was “undoubtedly” as a result of investigation.

WarnerMedia has not commented on the character of the “remedial motion,” and Fisher has not made the main points of his allegations about Whedon’s on-set habits public.

Whedon, in the meantime, has no introduced initiatives. His company, CAA, declined to remark.

Up to now, Whedon has stated nothing concerning the proliferating allegations in opposition to him. A number of individuals who spoke with Selection expressed a eager curiosity in how Whedon will reply. And extra importantly, how those that have been harm by him will heal.

Kate Aurthur and Cynthia Littleton contributed to this report.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here